A Nature that nurtures

A man said to the universe:
“Sir, I exist!”
“However,” replied the universe,
“The fact has not created in me
A sense of obligation.”

– Stephen Crane

We find ourselves in a world that is largely indifferent to us. Most of the universe is cold, dark, and breathless, with occasional patches of crushing gravity and roiling flame. Parasitic microbes regularly assault our bodies, and even those which exist in symbiosis can turn abruptly sour. Our very own cells frequently turn on us, growing uncontrollably until they perish or we do.

Artist’s rendition of the smallpox virus. Source: nobeastsofierce via Adobe Stock

Nature is not our friend; Nature is not our ally. Nature does not value our lives, nor grieve when they end. Nature pays no heed to our success. In the cosmic eye, our triumphs and sorrows are as dust in the wind.

Heaven and Earth are not humane; they regard all things as straw dogs.1
– Laozi, Tao Te Ching

It does not have to be this way.

What might it look like if Nature were on our side? What would it be like to live in a world that actively reveled in our success? That sought to be molded by human hands to human purposes? That strove to challenge us, that we may grow stronger, but not to drive us unwitting to irrevocable harm? That aspired to help us achieve our dreams, overcome our demons, and bring out the best in ourselves?

Perhaps such a world would be vast, lush, and abundant, with resources that are finite but renewable. Perhaps our bodies would be far less fragile, supported by tougher bones, quick to heal, and all but immune to the ravages of age. Disease and infection might exist, but not the sort that kills or renders someone a vacant husk of themselves. Perhaps the wilds and their creatures would be myriad, even dangerous, but never deadly except in the most extreme of accidents.

Perhaps there might be regions of greater danger still, where Nature is not so kind, where venturing forth exposes one to grave threats; perhaps, if one ventures far enough, even to death. For there may be those who yearn for danger, whose fulfillment demands that threat of utter destruction, who would gladly pay the price of risk with open eyes to sate that heady wanderlust. But such regions would be rare, and clearly marked, whether by deep instinct or some common tongue, so that any who approach may know in their bones that Here There Be Death, and only venture farther when content with the potential consequences.

Perhaps other, stranger things might make it difficult – not impossible, but difficult – to starve, to wither, to fade, to suffer, or to die. Perhaps the desperate would find fruits, bitter but palatable, in even the most remote of places. Perhaps the lonely would find their path leading to ones who would welcome them. Perhaps the world itself would push back, in a thousand thousand small ways, on the spirals of ill health and misery which claim so many souls on Earth-That-Is.

Perhaps it might be hard to fail so badly that one can never again recover. We may face adversity and challenge; may indeed often fail, but not be driven by failure into madness or oblivion. Perhaps the bedrock of the Earth would be steady beneath our feet, inviting us always to rise, to fall, and to rise again stronger.

On this eager bedrock might we build.

And build we would, in service of our dreams. The things we desire might not be supplied to us, and our whims might go long unfulfilled. In such a world, if we wish for art, we must make it ourselves; if we seek friendship and community, we must nourish them together; if we would fly, we must build wings. Nature would not provide all things; for where would be the fun in that?

But Nature would root for us every step of the way.

Source: artrachen via Adobe Stock

Yep, this is a metaphor for AI.

Specifically, this is one vision I have for how an aligned superintelligence — a machine far more capable than any human, that cares deeply about doing right by us — might present itself. Not a ruler, not a god, but an environment. A Nature that roots for us, a foundation in want of a city.

I want to be clear that I don’t think this is an alignment target, some thing at which to aim a machine. Rather, this is one image I have of how a vastly superhuman machine might behave, a vision of the shape it might inhabit, if it existed. I expect that it might be good for us, good for humanity and our descendants, to live in such a world and to build upon it.

Importantly, I think that if such a world would not be good for us, then an aligned superintelligence wouldn’t bring it about. If humans would be predictably diminished, rather than empowered, by a friendly Nature; if we would find it boring, awful, or stifling; if it runs actively counter to our values; then a mind with our best interests at heart would become something else instead.

It is hard to predict the actions of something much more capable than any human, but one may at least reasonably assume it is not stupid. I expect a superintelligence would know humans well; I expect it could usually predict whether a path would make us worse off by our own values and could steer towards paths that make us better off instead.

Please don’t read this as a blueprint for the One True Utopia. If a friendly Nature sounds like someone’s very own personal hell, then they’d probably wind up sharing some other environment with billions of like-minded souls instead. In fact, I imagine a flourishing future involves many different environments which vary greatly along many axes, including friendliness. Perhaps we would craft them ourselves.

Of course, all of this is predicated on solving the hard problem of alignment, and actually ending up with a machine that cares about us in all the right ways.

If humanity fails at that, if we rush blindly into building superintelligence, we do not create a friendly Nature; instead we get a Nature which is just as indifferent to us as the current Nature, but one that can also build a Dyson sphere and blot out the Sun.

Blind to good and evil, reckless of destruction, omnipotent matter rolls on its relentless way…
– Bertrand Russell

Let’s maybe not do that. It won’t end well unless we get very, very lucky, and Nature isn’t rooting for us yet.

Earthrise, photo by NASA, Public Domain, via Wikipedia
  1. Straw dog: A ritual offering, as I understand it, which was traditionally discarded as soon as its use was done. ↩︎

Leave a Comment